fbpx

Recipe by Brynie Greisman

Sandwich Fudge Squares

add or remove this to/from your favorites
Parve Parve
Easy Easy
35 Servings
Allergens

These squares are outstanding! They do take a little time, but they are so worth it. All my tasters went totally wild over them. They taste even better from the freezer. Thanks, HD.   Check out our complete collection of Rosh Hashanah recipes for mains, sides, soups, desserts, and more inspiration for the holiday.

Ingredients

Crust

  • eggs

  • 2/3 cup sugar

  • full 3/4 cup oil

Fudge Filling

  • 1/3 cup (2 and 1/2 ounces/70 grams) trans-fat free margarine (I recommend Earth Balance)

  • 1/4 cup oil

  • 2 tablespoons Gefen Cocoa Powder

  • 1 tablespoon instant coffee granules

  • 1 cup sugar

  • 1 and 1/2 tablespoons Gefen Vanilla Sugar

  • 5 and 1/2 ounces (135 grams) chocolate, broken into pieces

  • eggs

Garnish

  • confectioner’s sugar (optional)

Directions

Make the Fudge Squares

1.

Preheat oven to 350 degrees. Mix crust ingredients together in the order listed. Press two-thirds of the dough into a lined 9×13-inch (20×30-centimeter) pan. Freeze remaining dough (approximately one cup). Bake for 10 minutes or until just set. Remove from oven.

2.

Meanwhile, prepare the fudge layer: Melt together margarine, oil, cocoa, coffee, and sugars in a small pot over low heat, whisking occasionally. Add chocolate and stir together until well combined.

3.

Remove from heat. Add eggs, one at a time, whisking mixture thoroughly after each addition to achieve a fudgy consistency. Pour over baked crust and bake for seven minutes.

4.

Remove from oven and grate frozen dough over the fudge layer. It’s important to do this directly over the pan and not into a bowl, using a hand grater to achieve the small strip look, instead of a simple crumb look. Work quickly so the dough doesn’t get soft.

5.

Return pan to oven and bake for 20 minutes or until golden brown. Cool before cutting. Sprinkle with confectioners’ sugar before serving, if desired.

Notes:

These freeze beautifully.

Credits

Food and Prop Styling by Renee Muller Photography by Moishe Wulliger

Sandwich Fudge Squares

Please log in to rate

Reviews

Subscribe
Notify of
17 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Y S
Y S
4 years ago

amount of chocolate Recipe says: 5 and 1/2 ounces (135 grams) chocolate, broken into pieces

5.5 ounces is 154grams. What is the correct amount of chocolate, 154g or 135g?

Question
Mark your comment as a question
Raquel
Raquel
Reply to  Y S
4 years ago

5 and 1/2 ounces

Kayla
Kayla
5 years ago

Margarine How many sticks of margarine does 2.5 oz come out? Don’t have a kitchen scale. Mine just broke and didn’t have a chance to get a new one…

Question
Mark your comment as a question
Cnooymow{shman
Cnooymow{shman
Reply to  Kayla
5 years ago

One ounce is about 2 tablespoons.

Sarah
Sarah
5 years ago

Piece-y insteady of runny? I made these delicious squares for Succos and it was such a hit so I decided to make it again.
When working on the fudge over the flame I encountered a problem – the fudge wasn’t a liquid consistency once I poured all the ingredients in; it became piecey.
I tried again pouring in one ingredient at a time and had a smooth consistency until I got to the sugar. I tried pouring it in super slowly and stirring constantly but it became piecey even with just a bit of sugar added.(The vanilla sugar went in fine.)
Any ideas why this is happening – why the sugar is making the consistency piecey instead of runny?

Question
Mark your comment as a question
En}o}wah
En}o}wah
Reply to  Sarah
5 years ago

I also made these (and they are really delicious). The fudge ingredients were always “piecey”, until I added the eggs, I whisked them in one at a time and it all came together just fine.

[oymous
[oymous
Reply to  En}o}wah
5 years ago

The texture will be “piecey” but once you add in the eggs one at a time and whisk between each egg, it should become smooth and runny.

Nechama R
Nechama R
2 years ago

Amazing! simple but has a beautiful presentation. Best out of the freezer 😉

Yocheved Margulies
Yocheved Margulies
2024 years ago

Good with tweaks There is far too much cookie dough for the recipe to be balanced. I suggest dividing the dough into four, using two parts for the base, one part for the topping and the rest for something else. Even like this the cookie was quite thick. Another good idea is to make 1.5 times the fudge and use all the dough in a larger pan.

Shoshana
Shoshana
3 years ago

Good Fudge layer I didn’t care for the cookie layer, but the fudge layer was great. I’m thinking to use my own cookie recipe for the base next time or be creative with cookie flavors. this would be great warm over ice cream, but found it best to be served cold, straight from the freezer.

Esther Leah
Esther Leah
Reply to  Shoshana
3 years ago

I make these often. I have added a bit of almond extract to the base dough, and it tastes like marzipan. (Just a drop, 1/4 tsp.). And they really are good straight from the freezer!

Yaffa
Yaffa
5 years ago

Delicious! They were quite simple to make and I loved the gooey chocolate texture. I added just a bit of chocolate liqueur which gave it a very rich flavor.

Chaia Frishman
Chaia Frishman
Reply to  Yaffa
5 years ago

This is one of my favorite recipes too Yaffa!

Esther Leah
Esther Leah
6 years ago

Sandwich fudge cookies I made these for Shabbos. They were very easy to make, with a really pleasing texture, and not too sweet. Everyone enjoyed them. I will, bli neder, make these again!!

Chaia Frishman
Chaia Frishman
Reply to  Esther Leah
6 years ago

I love these Esther Leah. They remind me of Reisman brownie bars deconstructed.

Rebecca Smith
Rebecca Smith
6 years ago

Crowd Pleaser! Enjoyed by all guests, and someone commented that they were bakery caliber. I loved the subtle coffee edge to the chocolate filling.

Chaia Frishman
Chaia Frishman
Reply to  Rebecca Smith
6 years ago

Yes! Agreed Rebecca!