fbpx Chef It Up: Beef Wellington | Recipes
Close Menu

Chef it Up: Beef Wellington


Yossi: “Hey what about doing some British food for Kosher.com?” Sara: “Okay, give me a list of some haute British cuisine…” Yossi: “Sure, Fish n’ Chips, Chip Buttie…Mushy Peas?!” Sara: “I thought I said haute!! Why would anyone eat mushy peas?! If there’s one word that should never come after ‘mushy,’ it’s ‘PEAS!’” Yossi: “I know!! How about an old British classic…beef Wellington?”


Usually made with beef tenderloin, wrapped in a pate (often foie gras) and puff pastry, the Wellington is a succulent rich meal and only needs to be accompanied by a vegetable side (as it already packs in all the carbs and protein). Our version uses center of the rib eye (some kosher butchers might call it “fake filet mignon”), which is the most tender part of the best kosher steak. We then wrap that in mushroom duxelle and beef bacon to give it an extra rich flavor and finally, in the puff pastry. The technique is not the most simple so if it fails the first time…don’t worry! It has taken us many tries before we were able to create our delicious beef Wellington recipe. It’s a little technical, but once you get it down pat you’ll wow anyone!


Prepare the Duxelle


Heat olive oil in a saute pan until hot. Add onions and sweat until soft. Add mushrooms and garlic and cook over medium heat until all the water is evaporated.


Sprinkle in panko crumbs to absorb any remaining moisture.


You can add coconut cream at this point for additional richness, but it is optional. The texture of the duxelle should be like firm chummus.


Mushrooms duxelle is also great as a stuffing for boneless chicken thighs!

Assemble and Bake


Rub meat with olive oil, salt and pepper. Heat a cast iron skillet over medium heat. Add meat and sear for two minutes on each side. Transfer to a plate to cool.


Using a basting brush, spread mustard on steak.


Place a large piece of plastic wrap on a work surface. Lay out three to four strips of beef bacon horizontally. Spread mushroom duxelle evenly over the bacon.


Place the meat in the center and roll the bacon around the steak using the plastic wrap. Tighten at the edges and twist the ends to seal until it resembles a large sausage. Refrigerate for 30-60 minutes.


Preheat oven to 425 degrees Fahrenheit. Place puff pastry on a piece of plastic wrap.


Remove beef from fridge and cut off the plastic. Place the beef in the center of the puff pastry sheet, and fold in the sides. Trim the extras if necessary. Seal the edges with a little water.


Make three small diagonal cuts on the top of the log and brush with egg wash. Top with coarse sea salt.


Bake for 30-40 minutes until the internal temperature reaches 125 degrees Fahrenheit for rare. Let beef rest for 10 minutes before slicing into medallions.


Yield: 2 beef Wellingtons


Questions? You can reach Yossi and Sara on Instagram @tomatoes_tomahtos.

Photo by Esti Photography