I can’t believe it’s been over 25 years since I first tasted this amazing dish at my friend Rooksie’s Shabbos table. As a newlywed I was thrilled to add this to my sure-bet files. Special thanks to Mrs. Erie Gestetner for sharing this recipe (passed down from her Aunt Malchie, a”h).
Fill a large pot halfway with water and bring to a boil.
Drop fillets into boiling water and cook for 12 minutes. Turn off flame, but do not remove fish from pot.
Slice red onion and garlic cloves into a roaster pan.
Mix the remaining marinade ingredients together and pour over onion and garlic.
Carefully remove fish slices from water and lay on marinade. Spoon some marinade over each fillet. Cover with foil and refrigerate.
Notes:
The fish’s flavor intensifies as it sits. I recommend preparing this three days in advance.
Description:
Photography: Daniel Lailah.
Food Styling: Amit Farber.
Easy
Easy
Easy
Easy
Easy
Easy
Easy
Easy
What Cooks Are Saying
1 global rating
Photos from Our Community
See how these recipes turned out in real kitchens. Photos from home cooks will appear here as they're shared.
Tell Us How It Went: Share Your Experience
Your review could help someone decide what's for dinner tonight. Log in to join the conversation.
Log in to join the discussion2 Comments
Do you want to rate this post?
Edit your rating
Choose a new star rating and save it.
Moderation
Report
Kosher Comments
Kosher Comments
Add a link
Posting comment
Your comment will be posted in a moment...
Sugar sub Can I sub stevia for the sugar in this recipe or will it interfere with the marinating process?
I am not sure how Stevia works chemically. I don't see why it wouldn't add the taste needed though.The vinegar the pickling spice will do their job.
Thanks! Sugar is a preservative too, but hopefully the vinegar and pickling spices will be enough of a preservative here. Off to find out!
You can try honey or Silan (date syrup) instead of the sugar. Stevia liquid from experience gives a very bitter after taste, stevia powder may be better but not too much. Enjoy and come back to tell us how it worked out!!
If you are diabetic, silan is not really good, also agave. While they are sugar substitutes, they are still "sugar". Try splenda, it will give you the sweet without a bad aftertaste and not disturb you sugar level.
Back to report: It had a strong vinegar taste. I don't know if that's due to the amount of vinegar in the recipe or the stevia substitution, but not everyone went for it.
Thanks for letting us know Sarah!
Whenever I use stevia in a recipe that also has vinegar I use half vinegar and half water - sometimes even 1/3 vinegar and 2/3 water. Taste the liquid as you add the amounts to be sure it isn't too vinegary.
fish does this fish work with other fish like can i do the same recipe with flounder?
You can poach other types of fish and use the same sauce. We would recommend poaching flounder in a wide bottomed saucepan with about 1.5-2 cups of gently simmering water, so the fish doesn't fall apart. Flounder fillets will probably take 4-5 minutes to cook through, or until they flake easily and are opaque throughout. Let us know how it comes out!